---
title: "Wafer inspection discrepancies: write a disposition question that can be answered"
url: https://memory.wiki/w9MQByVS
updated: 2026-11-21T05:52:34.150Z
source: "api"
---
# Wafer inspection discrepancies: write a disposition question that can be answered

## Describe the observation first

A useful discrepancy report starts with what was observed on the delivered wafer or substrate. Identify the part, supplier lot, drawing revision and affected quantity. State the inspection method and the location of the observation. Keep a measured result separate from an interpretation of its cause, especially while the parties are still comparing their records.

## Point to the agreed requirement

Include the purchase requirement or drawing note that needs clarification. If the issue is an undefined condition rather than an apparent failure against a written requirement, say so. This helps the supplier answer the actual question without having to infer a new acceptance criterion from a photograph or an informal description.

## Preserve the supporting evidence

Retain the packaging labels and the original inspection data. Where photographs are useful, include scale, face and location references. Explain any handling or processing performed after delivery. Ask the supplier for the corresponding report or clarification needed to compare the records. Do not change the sample merely to obtain a clearer image without recording what changed.

## Ask for an explicit disposition

State whether the immediate question is document clarification, additional inspection, use as received, rework or replacement review. Keep any proposed concession separate from the normal specification and obtain the appropriate approval before use. When the issue is resolved, record the agreed action and its affected lot or pieces. Carry a lasting requirement change into the next controlled drawing revision instead of relying on an old email.

For project-specific material and processing enquiries, see [JXTSEMI wafer and substrate information](https://www.jxt-wafer.com/). Confirm the available material, achievable requirements and reporting scope for the actual order.


---

## Summary
Effective wafer discrepancy reports must clearly document observations and relevant requirements while providing supporting evidence to facilitate an explicit disposition. This process ensures that all parties align on the necessary actions and formalize any resulting changes to specifications.

## Themes
- wafer discrepancy reporting
- supplier communication standards
- quality assurance documentation
- disposition request process

## Key takeaways
- A discrepancy report must identify the specific part, lot, drawing revision, and quantity affected.
- The report should explicitly cite the purchase requirement or drawing note relevant to the issue.
- Evidence must include original packaging labels and inspection data with clear scale and location references.
- Disposition requests must specify whether the goal is clarification, additional inspection, use as received, rework, or replacement.
- Agreed changes to requirements must be incorporated into controlled drawing revisions rather than remaining in email correspondence.

## Insights
- Separating measured results from causal interpretations prevents bias during initial record comparisons.
- Informal descriptions or photographs should not be used as a substitute for explicit purchase requirements.
- Documenting post-delivery handling is critical to maintaining the integrity of the evidence chain.

## Open questions / gaps
- What is the specific escalation path if a supplier disagrees with the proposed disposition?

